Closed cases and updates
27 cases with outcomes or major updates, including solved homicides, people found or identified, and charges filed. Some investigations remain open.
-
Lucy M. Buchanan
Lucy was last seen on video walking near her apartment. Her remains were later found in nearby woods, and investigators found no evidence of foul play.
-
Jacob Mata
Jacob told his sister he was going camping and told friends he was headed to the Appalachian Mountains. He was driving a gray 1999 Toyota Camry.
-
Foot Doe
A canoeist found a human foot inside a black and white Nike shoe along the Cumberland River shoreline.
-
Marall Edwards
Marall was shot in his apartment during an apparent robbery. Three people were later indicted for first-degree murder.
-
Christopher Caris
Christopher and a co-worker were shot during an armed robbery at Bellacino’s restaurant on White Bridge Road while four others were forced to the floor.
-
Sheila Cummings
Sheila’s remains were found buried in the basement of a Charlotte Pike house. A former tenant confessed to killing her. DNA testing identified her decades later.
-
Liliana Rodriguez
Leaving an after-hours club with her brother and friends, Liliana was in the back seat of a black Ford Mustang when a black Infiniti G35 pulled alongside on I-24 and fired.
-
Philip Daniel Sydnor (formerly Barksdale Jane Doe)
DNA testing identified remains found on Barksdale Lane in 1991 as those of Philip Daniel Sydnor. The cause and manner of death are undetermined.
-
Donald Elden Verhalen (formerly Wall John Doe)
Donald died after falling from a wall near the downtown public library. He remained unidentified until investigators used genetic genealogy to learn his name.
-
Toni L. Gordon (formerly “Little Bit” Jane Doe)
Toni was found buried in the basement of a Charlotte Pike house in 1987; a former tenant confessed to her killing, and genetic genealogy identified her in 2026.
-
George Huddleston
A masked gunman approached George’s vehicle behind his home, made a demand and shot him as he sat with his wife, who was unharmed.
-
Kevin Blanchette
Kevin was found fatally shot near Montgomery and Douglas Avenues. In 2018, investigators identified the shooter through DNA evidence and an interview.
-
Henry Muncey (formerly Grassmere Doe)
Bones found in a creek near the Nashville Zoo were identified by DNA as Henry Muncey, who had been camping nearby.
-
William Ochterbeck
William’s brother reported him missing after he lost contact with him. William was later found safe in another state.
-
Deion Woodruff
A patrol officer found Deion at an intersection with gunshot wounds, apparently dropped there by a car. Two people were later indicted for first-degree murder.
-
Carolyn Fisher
Carolyn was found in a wooded area on the south embankment of I-40 near 28th Avenue North. She had been beaten and strangled.
-
Steven Allen Yantz (formerly Exit 52 John Doe)
Steven’s remains were found on a mattress in woods off I-24. Investigators used genetic genealogy to identify him years later.
-
Barkley Phillip Jones (formerly Charlotte Pike John Doe)
A mowing crew found Barkley’s remains in tall grass with a walking cane nearby. DNA testing later identified him.
-
Jacques Smith
Friends who came to Jacques’s Little Hamilton Street home found him on his bedroom floor. He may have been out driving a red Ford Mustang around 3 a.m.
-
Kinloch Wilkinson Jr. (formerly Browns Creek John Doe)
A volunteer picking up trash along Browns Creek found Kinloch’s skeletal remains. Genetic genealogy identified him years later.
-
Michael Dinnan
A surveyor found human remains at an old campsite in a vacant lot on Clifton Avenue. Investigators identified Michael using arrest and medical records.
-
Joshua Cole
Joshua and a co-worker were shot during an armed robbery at Bellacino’s restaurant on White Bridge Road while four others were forced to the floor.
-
Ashley Fuller (formerly Hwy 70 Jane Doe)
Ashley was found in an abandoned house used for shelter. Investigators identified her after a call from a relative and found no signs of foul play.
-
Michael Dewrell Webb
Michael lost contact with his family after arriving by bus from Minnesota. Vanderbilt police found him safe in August 2024.
