Update: Three days after the robbery, MNPD arrested Jason Bobo and Crystle Rutherford on two counts of criminal homicide each. Bobo confessed to shooting both men, pleaded guilty, and received two consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole. Rutherford was convicted and is serving an effective 50-year sentence, which the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals upheld in 2014.
At approximately 10:00pm on Friday, October 26th, 2007, Joshua S. Cole and Christopher R. Caris were shot during an armed robbery of Bellacino’s Restaurant located at 21 White Bridge Road.
Four other people in the business at the time were forced to lie down on the ground during the robbery but remained unharmed. One of them was able to get out a back door and run to call the police.
The two armed robbers, a black male and a black female, both wearing dark puffy coats and jeans, fled the restaurant. Joshua S. Cole was 18 years old at the time of his death.
Related case: Christopher R. Caris.
Case details
- Date
- October 2007
- Solved
- October 2007
- Case number
- 2007-663232
In the news
This case has been closed
It is no longer under active investigation. Hundreds of other Nashville cases still need someone to come forward.
