Cases from 1987
16 cases from 1987 in the files of the Metro Nashville Police Department Cold Case Unit. See each case and share what you know.
-
Kelly Kirby
Kelly and Bryan Crockett were found dead in their 37th Avenue North apartment when their roommate returned from Christmas with family. Both had been beaten and stabbed.
-
Bryan Eugene Crockett
Bryan’s brother returned from Christmas with family and found Bryan and Kelly Kirby dead in their 37th Avenue North apartment. Both had been beaten and stabbed.
-
John Jernigan
A teenage neighbor running an errand for John noticed a side door open that had been nailed shut, looked in and saw him on the living room floor.
-
Karen Lebo
Karen was found on the railroad tracks between 16th and 17th Avenues North, north of Clinton Street. She had died before the train approached.
-
Carolyn Phillips
Carolyn honked her horn when a man at her car window tried to rob her in a Gallatin Road Kroger lot. He shot her several times.
-
Jerome Walling
Known as Jerry, Jerome was found in his basement by his brother and father, who had come for Thanksgiving and could not find him for two days.
-
Marilynn Grisby
Also known as Marilynn Minor, Marilynn was found in a grassy field behind Church Street. She had last been dropped off at an alley where people gathered.
-
Sheila Cummings
Sheila’s remains were found buried in the basement of a Charlotte Pike house. A former tenant confessed to killing her. DNA testing identified her decades later.
-
Roderick Williams
Men yelled at Roderick in his car near Presslor Drive, walked up and shot him. When they tried to pull him out he drove off, sideswiping parked cars before stopping.
-
Island Skull John Doe
Two people fishing near Lower Nashville Island found a human skull on the shore and brought it to police. A search found no other remains.
-
Pamela Beasley
A couple found Pamela shot beside a building on Clinton Street. Earlier that day, she had gotten her hair done and dressed up.
-
Toni L. Gordon (formerly “Little Bit” Jane Doe)
Toni was found buried in the basement of a Charlotte Pike house in 1987; a former tenant confessed to her killing, and genetic genealogy identified her in 2026.
-
Robert Holland
Robert was shot after a man called him outside the Do Drop In Bar on Main Street. He died in 2004 from the injuries he suffered in the 1987 shooting.
-
John Hogsed
John was found unresponsive in an abandoned railroad car on the tracks off Oldham Street. He is believed to have been beaten the evening before.
-
Martha Vaughn
Martha’s nephew found her dead at home on Mansfield Street after she didn’t answer the phone. The medical examiner determined that she had been strangled.
-
Lee Pasquelle Woodard
Lee’s family lost contact with him, but he was not reported missing until nearly four years later.
